Stump the Scientist Scenes from AAAS Science After Hours


February 17, 2001

Nagging Math Mysteries
by Pearl Tesler

The best part about going to conferences like AAAS is that you really never know what you're going to get. Sure, there are the session titles, but invariably these, like horoscopes, have been broadly crafted to apply to a full range of possibilities.

Take "New Tests for Science". You could show up at this one expecting just about anything. Maybe there's literally a new test, something like a geeks' breathalyzer. Or maybe Science as a whole is facing a grave new challenge, like dissolution of the National Science Foundation, funder of all great and small. Or maybe they've isolated a science gene, using samples of Einstein's preserved brain.

It was in this "don't know what it is but it sounds good" spirit that I showed up at "The Nature and Origins of Mathematical Thought." Memorable gleanings related to this stated topic are nil. However, thanks to a few tangential asides, not one but two math mysteries that have dogged my days—and perhaps yours?—were finally solved.

Mystery #1: Why is it that a negative number times a negative number is a positive number? Now, there is some logic to the fact that a negative times a positive is negative. You can think of (-5) x 2 as two negative fives, which add up to negative ten. But a negative times a negative?

Math Mystery #1

The "aha" comes when you think of these numbers on a number line. Multiplication by a negative number is like a 180° rotation about the origin. So if you were pointing in the positive direction, multiplication by a negative "flips" you, so now you point in the negative direction. So if you're already negative, multiplication by another negative number flips you 180°, back to positive. Two negative multipliers are like a full 360° rotation, putting you right back where you started.

Mystery #2: Where did imaginary numbers come from, and why do we graph them on the vertical axis? This is one of those dogmas that gets handed to you in trig. The square root of 1 is 1, and the square root of -1 is i, an imaginary number. You put real numbers on the horizontal number line, and you put the imaginary numbers on a vertical axis.

Math Mystery #2

The plain truth is, they thought up i because they needed an answer to the question "What is the square root of -1?" But it begins to make some sense if you return to the idea that multiplication by -1 is a 180° rotation about the origin. By this logic, the square root of -1 (i) would have to be a 90° rotation. Where does that put you? Sticking straight up out of the origin. This is the imaginary dimension.

Both these insights come courtesy of George Lakoff and Rafael Nunez, co-authors of "Where Mathematics Comes From," a book on math cognition that seems to be about to become a national bestseller. Their premise is that all math has bases in the logic of the physical world. One simple example is the idea that more is "up" and less is "down." For example, prices "rise" and supplies "drop." Says Lakoff, "In no language in the world is this convention reversed." The idea is that math concepts like more and less tie directly to physical realities, for example, the level of water in a jug. Haven't read it yet, but it could be a cure for yet more nagging math mysteries.

<< Back to Dispatches