Skip to main content

What hitchBOT Can Teach Us About Ourselves

hmcdonald
August 14, 2015
Calculating...
What hitchBOT Can Teach Us About Ourselves
 

A photo posted by @hitchbot on

 

When I first learned of hitchBOT, I saw it as an intriguing inversion of a classic sci-fi theme. People were uneasy about robots before anyone outside a lab had even seen one. In I, Robot, Isaac Asimov reassured some readers with the Three Laws of Robotics, which essentially proposed that robots could be engineered to prevent harm to humans. But most portrayals in film and literature depicted much more sinister creatures. Could we really trust these creatures not to plot against us, enslave us, destroy us?

hitchBOT turned these questions around by asking not whether we can trust robots, but whether they can trust us. And that’s why hitchBOT was also an intriguing mashup of technology and social psychology. What determines how we react to someone (or something) in need? How do we respond to a request by an individual different from ourselves? What prompts us to trust, or to withhold trust? Behavioral scientists have been studying these questions for decades.

And these aren’t just academic questions or social party games. Questions of trust and cooperation are at the heart of many of the world’s biggest challenges, from arms races and international conflict to ecosystem collapse and climate change. Studying how we work together (or don’t) tells us about ourselves, but can also shed light on ways to solve problems that threaten us all. (And that’s why the Exploratorium created the Science of Sharing exhibition: to facilitate experimentation with trust and cooperation and discussion of how they work at societal scales.)

As it turned out, the question at the heart hitchBOT was prophetic: poor hitch couldn’t trust us. Its journey across the U.S. (planned to end at the Exploratorium) came to an early end when vandals decapitated it in Philadelphia. In the aftermath, many focused on location. The “city of brotherly love” came in for a lot of criticism, as did America itself. Smiling, defenseless hitchBOT made it across Canada and parts of Europe with no ill effects, but couldn’t travel more than a few hundred miles on America’s mean streets without suffering a senseless death. Doesn’t that mean there’s something wrong with Philly, or with Americans in general? Aren’t we just jaded, brutal, violent?

But as with any conclusion about human behavior, the truth is more nuanced. There may indeed be cultural differences between Canadians and Americans, but similarities in how people deal with issues of trust and helping and humor are likely to be more common. hitchBOT didn’t make it safely across Canada because there are no bad or violent Canadians, but because it didn’t happen to encounter those folks on its journey. We’d learn more about what happened if we studied vandalism rates and population densities along the robot’s route than if we simply see the lesson as “Canadians good, Americans bad.”

And there’s reason to be optimistic. Yes, some commenters raged about American nastiness, but the outpouring of response also included big doses of sadness and empathy. Thousands were excited about hitchBOT and touched by what happened. People felt bad and wanted to help. (Yes, Americans, too. Even people from Philadelphia!) Basically, many reacted as if hitchBOT was a person, a living creature deserving of emotional connection and support. In the end, the little robot’s destruction illuminated as much about the human capacity for empathy as did any of the rides it caught when it was alive. (“Alive?” Not the right word, but it’s hard to write about robots without making them seem like living beings.)

What did hitchBOT tell you about trust, cooperation, and empathy? And have you experienced Science of Sharing?