Light Walk by Bob Miller

Bob Miller’s Light Walk invites you to explore sunlight, pinholes, images, and shadows in ways that change how you see light itself.
History of the Light Walk
Bob Miller first started taking friends outside the Exploratorium to show them his discoveries about images and sunlight in the summer of 1975. At the time, he was building the now deaccessioned exhibit Holes in a Wall and was fascinated with the way single images of the Sun that shone through pinholes could combine in many unexpected ways. It wasn't long before he became convinced that all light is in the form of images. He set out to show this in a series of exhibits that include Image Mosaic, Christmas Tree Balls, Sophisticated Shadows, and others.
Over the years, Bob's Light Walk (nee Image Walk) has become an Exploratorium institution. It has been nourished continually by the comments and questions of visitors, interns, Explainers, and other Exploratorium staff. A Light Walk can last an hour, or a day. It always begins outside the museum with a single image of the Sun, and it ends inside with exhibits on images and shadows. It can lead almost anywhere. Bob Miller has created many of the best-loved exhibits on light and color, including the Sun Painting.
The light explorations below are described by Bob Miller.
It Begins Here
"It begins here, with a commonly observed and reported phenomenon: the light coming through the cracks between the leaves in the trees hits the ground or a piece of white cardboard and is round. Now you know that the spaces between the leaves aren't round. They're all irregular. The round spots of light are images of the Sun.
"One thing that occurred to me when I looked at this was that there must also be an image of the sky surrounding the Sun. The light from the sky must get through the holes, too. But we aren't normally aware of it, because the blue light of the sky is so dim compared to the Sun. The Sun is really bright, about a million times brighter than the moon. And the moon is even brighter than the clear blue sky."
Clouds
"Now it turns out that sometimes by chance, if the Sun is partially covered or surrounded by clouds or fog, then around each one of these Sun images, you actually see the clouds going by.
"The reason the Sun shows up so well is that it is so bright. But actually, each hole also lets through a complete image of whatever is on the other side, including the sky, the houses, the people."
Here
"Another way to think of it is this: When you put your eye somewhere, you can see everything around you: houses, trees, cars, people. Why? Because of the light that's coming right here into your eye. Now if I move out of the way, there's still light going through this little area in space, right there.
"And it must contain all the information of the scene—the complete detail and color and everything—because otherwise I wouldn't be able to see it when I put my eye there. So that means that here, and here, and here—every little area in space—there is in the light all the information about the complete scene of where the light is coming from, whether it's being reflected or emitted from a lightbulb or whatever, even from behind you. If I turn 180º around, I can see the scene that's over there, too. And it's all contained in the light. The light that's invisible. you can't see it as it passes through this little area in space. All that information is encoded in the light, in the frequency—the different colors—in the brightness and in the direction it's traveling. And it's moving through there pretty fast, at 186,230 miles per second, in fact."
Crescents
"Once you start noticing these images, they're all over the place. You can just make a hole in your hand, and there is the hole in my hand making an image of the Sun. We had a partial eclipse of the Sun here a few years ago, and instead of round Sun images, each one of them was a crescent shape."
Boards
"Okay, so now we have a whole bunch of them. Instead of using the holes in between the leaves, we can use the holes in a board. I cut out a whole series of holes: there's a little square hole, a triangular hole, a circular hole, and a very irregular hole."
Rounds
"If I hold that board up sort of perpendicular to the Sun—no matter what the shape of the hole—I still get a round image of the Sun, because the Sun is round. And so the image is going to be round, too.
"And if it's a small hole or a bigger hole, all the images are the same size, and as you move back, they all get larger. The image gets bigger the farther back you move because the light diverges more. But it also gets dimmer, because no matter where you put the board, you still have the same amount of light coming through the hole. It's just spread out more."
Pinholes
"Now this was really interesting to me, because I had always thought that a pinhole was just that, that you could only get an image with a little tiny hole. It turns out that you can have any size aperture, and any shape, and as long as you get back far enough with the screen, it will resolve itself into just about as good an image of the Sun as you get with a little pinhole close up.
"One way to see this is to use just the square hole. You can take just this little tiny comer of the square hole and make a little tiny image with the light coming through that corner. Now about a quarter of an inch away, there's another tiny image coming through the other corner. So now there's an image there, and an image there, about a quarter of an inch apart. But now, as I pull back, both images get bigger and bigger.
"But their centers are no farther apart than that—about a quarter of an inch, so by the time the images have gotten real big, the centers are effectively in the same place. So you have a single large image of the Sun, with a quarter-inch fuzzy edge. The limit of the resolution is the size of the aperture."
"If I cross the fingers of my hands, I can make a whole bunch of Sun images with the light coming through the holes. Now if I take my hands away, light that was coming through the holes in my fingers is still passing through there. And it must be still coming there in that form, because when I put my hands there, then you can see that the images are "really" there. But you can also say in a sense that they are always potentially there, that the information is always there."
Pegboards
"Now here's a pegboard full of holes. If we tip it up pretty perpendicular to the Sun, it makes a whole bunch of Sun images. As I start to back up, they get bigger and bigger.
"If I drilled still another hole in the board, it would let still another image through. So I could keep drilling holes, and every time I drilled a hole I'd let an image through. In fact, I could drill so many holes that I'd drill the whole board away, and then I'd have that.
"That's what I used to think of as uninteresting diffuse white light. But there's a tremendous amount of information in the light that's on that board.
"One of the nice byroducts of this is that, as I back up, the images overlap and you begin to get some nice patterns. Some of the images are dimmer than others. That just means that hole is smaller for some reason. Sometimes you'll see a really bright one, and that means the hole is bigger."
Slits
"Now here's a couple of slits in a board. Again, as I pull back further, the streaks of light get bigger and bigger. But anywhere along there, if I block it off with my fingers, you can see that it's just a row of images of the Sun that are all lined up. And in any place in that slit, you can see a round image of the Sun."
Squares
"Here's a board with square holes in it. We see that if I pull that back far enough, you get round images of the Sun."
Mirrors
"Now here's a board with little square mirrors in the place of the square holes."
"What led up to this was a couple of things. I bought a glass mirror for the Sun follower on the roof, and I was worried about it not being flat enough. So I took it outside the door and I reflected sunlight into and across the museum to the far wall. I never really thought about what I expected to see. I guess I expected to see a nice, rectangular spot of sunlight over there.
"Well, I didn't. It was quite rounded. And just by chance, the fog was coming in that day, and every now and then the fog would go right near the Sun so that the whole wall was filled with an image of the sky. You could see the slightly out-of-shape bright spot of light that was an image of the Sun, and then you could see the fog going by. It really got me excited for two reasons."
Aperture
"Because a mirror is really a reflecting pinhole, it just reflects the light that would go through the hole. So if instead of putting square holes here, I put square mirrors, I get a reflection of the images that would go through those holes.
"I also realized that aperture size was just about limitless. Here was a 30- by 46-inch mirror. Now that's certainly not a pinhole, but over there on the wall 130-feet across the museum floor, the resolution became so good that you could actually recognize the Sun and the clouds and the fog going by."
Reversed Images
"Now I'll move over here into this fuzzy shadow, and I'll make an image of the Sun with my hand again. Now you can see an image of the Sun with an image of the tree in front of it. You can see the silhouette of the branches in front of the Sun in the same way that you can see the silhouette of the moon in front of the Sun in a partial eclipse. Of course, it's upside-down, and also left-right reversed."
A Bare Branch
"Now there's a bare branch in front of the Sun image, blowing in the wind. Here's a whole array of them through the pegboard. You can see that through every hole there's a different image. Every hole is a slightly different viewpoint. From image to image, the changes are very slight, but from the right-hand side of the board to the left-hand side of the board, the images are very different. In fact, you can't see much similarity between what's on the right-hand side of the board and what's on the left-hand side of the board.
"So this really gave me an insight into the question, what is depth of field? A pinhole image is always pretty much in focus, and even if you move the board back and forth, everything is pretty much in focus: the branch that is very near and the Sun that is very far away are both in focus."
Lenses
"Now, in any one of these images on the pegboard, you see a nice clear image of the branch and a nice, clear image of the Sun. But if you take a picture and use a lens lens right next to the pegboard, the little images of the Sun are all bent in toward the center."
Prisms
"You can regard a lens as a whole collection of pinholes, each one of which is covered with a little prism that simply bends the light. It's ground in such a way that each little prism bends all the images into the center where they all overlap. All those images have been squeezed in toward the center."
Overlaps
"But if I have a very large-aperture lens—this one's about 8 inches in diameter—then it's going to try to take this image over here and overlap it with that image over there, which is 8 inches away, and those images are very different."
Silhouettes
"This image has a silhouette of the branch in front of it, and this one's got images of leaves in front of it. So if you took all those images and stacked them, you'd either have to choose whether you'd stack the images of the Sun or the images of the tree."
Depth of Field
"This is what depth of field is, because if you use a little lens that's only as big as one hole, then the branch and the Sun are both going to be in focus. But if I use a large-diameter lens, then I'm trying to overlap an image from over here with an image from over there, which is very different."
Thumbs Up
"You can see what causes this if you look at houses in the distance and hold a thumb up. Then alternately look through one eye, then the other eye. You see that your thumb shifts relative to the background; it appears in a different place. One eye sees the thumb in front of one house, and the other eye sees the thumb in front of another house, and there's no way I can take those two images and line them up, because they're so different.
"With a large-aperture lens, you can't line up both the near thing and the far thing. If you have the person in the foreground in focus, then the person in the background will be fuzzy. But if you use a very little lens, such as a pinhole, then both the near things and the far things can be in focus. To get the image in focus with a large lens, you have to decide whether you want to put the screen where the Sun images are lined up, or where the branches are lined up."
Hand Shapes
"I showed how you can make a hole out of your hand to get a pinhole image. So just on impulse, I cut out the shape of a hand and drilled a hole in it. Especially in the summer, the Sun is so high that you can't get your hand up there far enough back to get a nice, big image, but with this, you can. So now you can see a pretty good-sized image of the Sun, with a lot of leaves in front of it."
Mirrored Hands
"But what was fun was that I made the hand out of a mirror. So that means that whatever light the hand is blocking, since it's made out of a mirror, I can reflect that light over here to a board. So this, in effect, really is the bright side of a shadow. This is the very light that the hand is blocking, not letting it reach the board."
Dark Spots
"Now let me find a silhouette of that big branch up there. There's a silhouette of the branch in front of the image of the Sun on the board. But now look at the light that's reflected. What's that dark spot in the palm of the hand? That's the reverse image of the Sun. There's a hole in the palm of the hand, so that light can't be reflected, right? But the light that goes through the hole in the palm of the hand is an image of the Sun with a silhouette of a branch in front of it. So that image is missing from the reflected light. You see a dark image of the Sun with a white silhouette of a branch in front of it!"
Shadows
"This then led to the half of the Sophisticated Shadows exhibit where you can see that a shadow is a missing image.
"The shadow of a butterfly or the shadow of an airplane, if it's high enough, is actually round because it's blocking an image of the Sun. Here's a sort of positive way to show that. Through all these holes in the outline of the plane, you have an image of the Sun going through each place. Now if I pull this back farther and farther, the images of the Sun keep getting bigger and bigger, but their centers never get any farther apart. So at some point, when you get back far enough, each one of these images of the Sun will be so big that they'll resolve into one large image of the Sun."
Negatives
"The negative of that—the complement of that—would be if I had a transparent panel with little black dots in the outline of a butterfly and each dot blocked an image of the Sun. As I pulled back farther and farther, those shadows would be bigger and bigger and would resolve into a large single missing image of the Sun. And the limit of the resolution would be the size of the butterfly or the airplane."
Spectrums
"Now there's an image of the Sun coming through this hole again. You can also say that there's a red image of the Sun there, a blue image of the Sun, a green image of the Sun. There's an image of the Sun for every frequency that's in sunlight. If I put a little prism over the pinhole, it shifts the blue image of the Sun over quite a ways, and the green a little less.
In other words, you could spread that out into what you call a spectrum, or a rainbow. But what that really is is a whole series of colored images of the Sun that normally are all stacked right on top of each other and you see that as white. But if you put the prism there, then just as if you took a pile of pennies and smeared them sideways you can see all the colored images of the Sun. Then that's the fun thing, because the Sun also makes infrared images, and ultraviolet images, and x-ray images. Anything you say about the visible light is true of all radiation. Radiation is information. The information is an image of where the radiation is coming from. Shadows of any kind of radiation are actually complementary images."
A Sea of Images
"So what I used to think of as uninteresting diffuse white light turns out to be pretty damned interesting. If you think of every little area in space containing, in the light, all the information for a full-color, completely detailed image of things both nearby and far away— here in this little area of space, and here . . . and here—then it seems to me that we're walking around all the time in an invisible sea of images.
All you have to do to see one of them is to put your eye right 'here' and let in one of those little specks of light. And on top of all that, you see it 'out there,' projected on the real world. Wow!"


