Skip to main content

Prototyping and iteration

luigi luigi
May 18, 2010
Calculating...
Prototyping and iteration

The video above shows one of the ways in which we tend to move from an initial idea, an inspiration, to something more concrete, something that works as we intend to.

A few days ago, Walter told me: "Today, I just want to make a marble launcher". His inspiration was those tennis ball or golf ball launchers that are basically two wheels spinning in opposite directions, trapping the ball, and shooting it forward. He envisioned it as a marble wall element that kids could spin really fast when a marble was approaching, and make it go up an incline.

By the end of the day, he had a working prototype make with scrap pieces of wood and foamies. As I understand Walter's process, this was kind of a "proof of concept", a way of reassuring himself that his vision actually works in the real world.

Then the game became about how to make it better, battery powered, more powerful, etc. In other words, how to "plus" the idea. The first iteration was with LEGO parts and a LEGO motor, because it was easy and quick to put together a contraption that worked and had the right dimensions. Alas, it lacked oomph (it was not "dangerous" enough).

So, to overcome the limitations of the anemic LEGO motor, Walter started thinking about pneumatic tubes, reversing a vacuum cleaner so it would blow air, using bellows to charge a compressor, while at the same time experimenting with other motors we had around. The 3V hobby motors we use for Scribbling Machines do spin really fast, so I suggested he try one of those.

It worked too well! It spun so fast that the rubber tires on the LEGO wheels expanded due to centrifugal force and slipped off the rim. A different solution was needed.

In the end, the final solution (for now!) incorporated elements of the initial prototype: quickly produced wooden elements and rubber bands; but it also used concepts learned during the intermediate prototype fase: using a motor and a switch, and tying the motor with a loose ziptie so that it has some "give" when the marble gets underneath it: this serves the same function that the upper tire did in the previous iteration.

now we're starting to think about how to use this marble launcher to make a fast elevator to bring marbles back up to the top of the wall! The challenge will be how to slow them down once they're at the top so they can begin a second descent. Stay tuned for updates once we figure it out...