Carlos came to the Tinkering Studio a few weeks ago, and spent almost two hours building a marble machine contraption. Sarah, who's been working with us to document what happens in the space, and articulate what is it that people "get" from our activities, and how, was there recording his progress, alternatively helping him and asking him questions about his process.
After he was done, Sarah asked if he wouldn't mind being interviewed about what he just did, and recorded his words and thoughts about his own process, the parts that were challenging, and the parts that were fun (which often were the same, it turns out!).
This is a new direction that we're experimenting with, in trying to really answer the question: what is it that is so compelling and rich about tinkering?
Two things really stood out for me. The first is that Carlos takes over another kid's marble machine, and leaves a large portion of it essentially untouched, and still, at the end, expresses a very clear statement of ownership ("this is the second most complicated thing I ever made"): so at what point does he come to "own" somebody else's work? What makes it his? Is it the fact that in order to fiddle and tinker with it he had to build an internal representation of how it works? In other words, does understanding constitute ownership?
The second interesting bit about this is that having an interview with Carlos after he was done allowed us to explicitly confirm some qualities of his interaction that normally we would have to infer. For example, one of our design goals for our activities is to build on a participant's previous interests and knowledge. It's hard to know whether you've actually done so, short of just assuming that most kids have a previous interest in rolling marbles and building fanciful contraptions. But in this case, we got a nice confirmation from Carlos himself that he "likes to do this sort of thing", and has built runs for model cars at home from everyday materials.
I hope this video begins to communicate how personally meaningful spending a few hours "thinking with your hands" can be, and that it moves us along in our attempt to answer that dreaded question: it looks like fun, but what are they really learning?