I've been thinking a lot lately about how to encourage and foster a certain quality, while playing with circuits, that for lack of a better word I'm going to call "creativity."
[A tirade about why I think creativity is an overused term that doesn't define anything useful is perhaps better left to a separate post...]
Most of the time we like to structure our tinkering with circuits around an activity we call Circuit Boards. At first glance, it could seem like a trivial implementation of a simple idea: put a bunch of simple basic circuitry components on a table with some alligator clips, and let people figure out how to wire them up together.
But something about the way we offer those materials and which materials we offer allows for what Mitchell Resnick calls "wide walls" (you can try many different things) and "high ceiling" (you can get very complex with what you try), while still keeping the "low threshold" that means almost anyone can play with it. Here are some recent example of things people made with circuit boards that I think would meet most people's definition of "creative."
Dominic spent about 45 minutes playing with circuits at Maker Faire. After figuring out how to wire a switch, he started hooking up many batteries together. I just made sure he knew not to short them and didn't use any 9V batteries, but let him explore what could have seemed like a somewhat fruitless (if mildly dangerous) exercise. 25 minutes later he came to find me because he wanted to show me what he had made.
This was in a very different context: at a professional museum workers' conference in Minneapolis, MN we hosted a session on the "making" culture and its place in a museum setting. I brought Circuit Boards and Squishy Circuits for people to play with, and this young fellow made a rather complex circuit where the motor is continuously powered, while the buzzer is only activated when a switch is closed, then made the motor's motion part of the switch.
And finally, I think Squishy Circuits takes the creativity quotient to yet another level, adding the possibility of expressing a measure of personal aesthetic within the circuit that you design. We have not played around long enough with this to collect a large number of particularly creative outcomes, but I think this clown face with a functioning propeller hat and light-up nose definitely qualifies.
I think some of the qualities that allow for this sort of deep and innovative interactions to happen are:
- The components are recognizable and familiar elements: lightbulbs in simple holders, batteries, alligator clips. They communicate what they are, for the most part, and don't look "fancy" or a specialty item you couldn't buy at RadioShack.
- The activity is arranged around a central, round table, with no physical demarcation between facilitators (or "experts") and participants. The whole exploration happens in an atmosphere of shared investigation, rather than a teacher/learner dichotomy. This aspect in particular is hugely important, I think, as something like circuitry tends to bring out the "know it all" in engineer types and electrically-minded people...
- There are no instructions and no clearly stated goal to the activity. There is no challenge to meet, which means there is no intimidation factor (other than whatever preconceived notion people might have about their own affinity for circuits). But it also means that there is no point at which you can say "I've done it." If the goal is to wire up a house with a switch, once you've achieved that you tend to stop searching for something else you might try, but if there is no specific thing the activity asks you to accomplish, you become your own navigator. This tends to actually take people deeper into an investigation than an externally imposed goal.
- The materials allow for unexpected and serendipitous things to happen. On the way to figure out how to put a switch into a circuit you might find out what a short circuit is, or randomly make a reverse switch that turns on when it's open instead of closed. All of a sudden, what you weren't trying to do might become much more compelling and cause deeper exploration than what you were trying to accomplish.
- Finally, I can't overemphasize the importance of thoughtful and skilled facilitation. Even with all these scaffolding measures in place, tinkering with circuits is quite the frustrating experience at times, and the right word or action at just the right time makes all the difference between giving up and getting that nice jolt of insight.