Iteration on an initial idea is a core principle of our process in the Tinkering Studio. We are constantly refining, rearranging, and revisiting themes we've explored in the past. We also love to riff on experiments we see happening at other science centers, whether they're activity ideas, materials storage solutions, ways of creating environments, and more.
Art bots, like our scribbling machines, a set of activities that we, and many other museums, have experimented with. At this year's ASTC conference, we had the opportunity to see how many other institutions have played around with the idea of using different materials to create trace-making objects.
Many of the art bots shared started with a motor with an offset weight to create vibration. The vibration allowed the bots to move around the table in different ways. Dana from TELUS Spark shared their version of bristle bots that travel through salt to trace their motion. They use a camera to take a timelapse of the table so visitors can see how the bots change the surface over time.

Elena from Explora shared how they complexified traditional scribbling machines by adding switches made from common household materials. Brads, paperclips, foil, wire, cardboard, and clothespins were just some of the items they combined to invent switches that controlled when the machine would scribble and pause.
Keith from Science Museum of Minnesota shared the kit-like set of materials they use for scribbling machines (or in this case, splatter bots) for weekend workshops. I loved the "engines" they made by attaching the motor and battery pack to a flat piece of wood. One or more could be added to or moved around on the scribbling machine as you built. The clear tubing to create a testing ring is an ingenious (and easily portable!) solution to stop them from flying off the table.
Anitra from Tulsa Children's Museum saw the tubing and told me they use it for art bots too - but in a completely different way. They use it as an offset weight material to make the motors vibrate. They have also developed a system to make connecting the motor to the battery easier for younger visitors. They attach paper clips to the motor and battery pack leads, then use a binder clip to hold the connection when it's time to test. Another idea she shared was hacking an electric toothbrush bought at a dollar store to make a bristle bot. That way, it already has a switch to turn it on and off, and is a fun way to get inside an everyday object.
That reminded me of a variation on bristle bots that we saw at the Tech Museum of Innovation on a visit a few months ago. They had an assortment of brushes, from large scrub brushes to small nail brushes and more, that you could use to make bristle bots of all shapes and sizes. There was velcro on the brushes, motors, and battery packs to allow you to make changes quickly and iterate on your ideas. The offset weights were a material I had never tried before too - small colorful erasers!

At ASTC Bridget from the Tech shared a variation on a trace-making art bot that didn't use a motor at all. Workshop participants used LEDs and light weight materials to make light-up wind tube fliers. They captured the traces these fliers made using the Glow Doodle app. You could observe the patterns how your flier spun, floated, bounced, or zoomed out of the tube over time with the light traces.
Monika from the Lawrence Hall of Science shared a brand new idea they've been prototyping that uses a MakeyMakey attached to a scribbling machine that instead of making visual traces makes musical art. I love the idea of using these bots to explore sound, and want to continue messing around with that idea.
We brought the chalk scribbling machines that we began experimenting with for Maker Faire 2013. We weren't able to use the solar panels since we were testing inside, but even with them being battery powered it was a good way to open up the discussion on the possibilities of ways you can iterate on art bot ideas.
One iteration we didn't share at ASTC but have prototyped in the past are nature bots. We collaborated with Leslie Henslee of the Frankenart Mart in San Francisco to develop an activity around the idea of "toys gone wild." This version of art bots had elements similar to Dana's, where the creations trace pathways through sand, but also incorporate elements of the outdoors and the challenges of working with a totally different materials set.
Reflecting on the diversity of all these approaches around a theme makes me wonder: what can we try next?