Skip to main content

Parts, Purposes, and Complexities with Explainers

Ryan Ryan
November 17, 2015
Calculating...
Parts, Purposes, and Complexities with Explainers

Over the past year or so, we have been experimenting with visible thinking routines developed by the Agency by Design group which is an initiative in the larger Project Zero project. In our trainings and workshops, we spend a lot of time planning the the materials and environments that are best suited for tinkering and recently these thinking routines have given us a great starting point to turn our attention equally to how we organize reflections and conversations for professional development workshops.

In the Tinkering Studio there are a group of about fifteen high school explainers who have self-identified as being interested in learning more about tinkering,setting up the space and facilitating activities on weekends and evenings. This group participates in weekly trainings where we try out activities together and spend time analyzing our role as facilitators. It not always easy to develop a reflective practice, so we've experimented with lots of different ways to prompt discussions about facilitation like looking at photos, watching videos, coming up with challenging topics, and delivering more specific presentations. For the first discussion with the new group this semester, I was interested in trying out a thinking routine to help make their ideas more tangible and make it easier for them to feel comfortable sharing their thoughts with each other.

IMG_4167 A routine that we've tried previously in a modified way as a framework for toy dissection called 'parts, purposes, and complexities' allows participants to slow down and make careful observations about an object or system. In this exercise, participants are asked to look at something and write or draw all the pieces or components, the purposes of the parts, and think about how it's complicated between the purposes and the parts. IMG_4168In the tinkering workshop area, the project explainers are currently making cardboard automata with visitors on weekends. So I thought we would start the training with a warm up to get used to the thinking routine by analyzing the physical automata examples. We divided into pairs and started observing the parts of the mechanism (cams, cam followers, shafts, cranks, frames etc...) the purposes for the parts, and the complexities inherent in the system. We recorded these three aspects in different colored markers on white paper covering the tables. While I planned this originally as simply an introduction to the thinking routine, I think it could be a really effective tool on it's own for allowing facilitators to really reflect on the objects that visitors are creating and deconstruct the ways that they successfully (or otherwise) making something to meet their goals.

IMG_4170After we spent about thirty minutes analyzing the physical objects, we turned to the more difficult task of using the routine to reflect on our role as facilitators. For this part of the workshop, we had the group divide up into three groups that would each focus on spark, sustain, or deepen (three phases of facilitation that we have introduced previously). For this discussion we had to slightly redefine the categories. First we talked about the 'parts' of facilitation, which includes all the things that we say or do in the space when interacting with visitors. Each group wrote down their ideas and shared their thoughts for their phase of facilitation. We allowed time for others to add comments about what they have tried or ask questions of the group. The we got into "the purposes of the parts" or the whys for actions of facilitators in the space. Some of these seemed to be more straightforward, for example smiling helps to create a more welcoming atmosphere. But others facilitation moves like "asking questions about their work" could have multiple purposes from better understanding their contraption to building self efficacy. I hoped that this discussion would begin to surface some of the goals that the group had for participants both during and after the activity. IMG_4176For the complexities part of the discussion we focused on thinking about the ways that these moves and purposes are complicated by the reality of the floor. There are many issues related to time, space, parents, and younger kids. Through surfacing some of these things that we spend a lot of time thinking about and coming up with strategies to deal with, we could start to think up more in-depth topics for future trainings.

For me, the hope in this type of training is that these explainers will be able to look at their facilitation in the space as something where they are constantly prototyping, trying new techniques, and learning from us and each other. But for that to happen, we have to be clear together about the goals for the visitors to the space and some of the foundational techniques that help to support the learning that happens through tinkering. I plan to continue tweaking this and other thinking routines so that we can be engaged in a continuing conversation together about facilitation in the tinkering studio space.