Skip to main content

EU workshop - Toy Dissection

Ryan Ryan
December 31, 2014
Calculating...
EU workshop - Toy Dissection

For the EU Tinkering workshop in Milan we decided to try out some new ways of organizing conversations abour for several of our activities based on Karen's visit with a group from Harvard called Project Zero who develop 'visible thinking' routines. We thought that some of these different methods for structuring discussions might be interesting for our debriefing tinkering activities.

Milan Tinkering Workshop

But with Toy Dissection, we decided to not only experiment with the format for the discussion after the activity, but also modified the set-up for the activity to emphasize certain aspects of the tinkering process.

Milan Tinkering Workshop

Some of our group and the educators from MUST (who had done the activity before) took the role of 'observer', chose one group, and jotted down copious notes about the participants process during the dissection.

Milan Tinkering Workshop

We also gave each pair a large sheet of paper and a black marker and asked them to identify all the parts that they could see, hear, or feel before investigating the insides of the toy. Some people wrote about the components using descriptive language and others drew their best guesses for what they would find underneath the fuzzy exterior of their singing and dancing toy.

Milan Tinkering Workshop

After a good amount of time for initial descriptions, we handed out the scalpels, surgical scissors, and wire snippers and gave each group the usual instructions to try and dissect the toy while "keeping it working" as long as possible.

Milan Tinkering Workshop
At this point we also handed out green pens so that groups could revise and update their big paper as they discovered the beautiful and complicated parts under the surface of the contraption.

Milan Tinkering Workshop
As an "observer" in the activity I heard the group having lots of discussions about the predictions that they made before cutting into the toy and which were "right" or "wrong". The great thing about the process was that it didn't assign a value to either of those things; people in my group were as excited to see they things that the correctly predicted as they were to discover surprises that they hadn't counted on.

Toy Dissection Notes
Taken together the wonderfully detailed notes recorded on the big paper by participants and the presence of a observer led to some really interesting conversations about the process of making predictions, working collaboratively, and investigating the workings of the machines. I think it was really good practice for myself as an "observer" to stand back and watch an entire interaction of a group, since as a facilitator I find myself moving around a lot, just getting little pieces of each groups process as clues to decide when to stand back and when to jump in.

Milan Tinkering Workshop
I think this was a great experiment to really help workshop participants to be aware of their own thinking process. Ideally in a workshop, people will be engaged learners in the tinkering activities while keeping in mind the implications of their process for their roles as educators and designers. What I like about thinking tools like the ones we tried for toy dissection is that they help participants keep track of their thoughts in the moment so that they can use that direct experience to go deeper in reflections and conversations as we debrief the activity.