Pea Sorter
There’s a lot of variety among peas, and among individuals of any species. To understand this diversity, scientists often make categories. Try to create meaningful categories by sorting peas.
Fill a small cup with about 50 dried peas.
Make a sorting trough:
- Take the sheet of paper, and make a fold about two inches from the long edge.
- About halfway between that fold and the edge, make a second fold in the opposite direction.
Place the paper so this accordion fold forms a sorting trough that will hold a line of peas. (Click to enlarge the photo below.)
Take a close look at your peas. Use a magnifying lens if you have one. What differences do you notice among them in color? In texture? Do you notice any other differences?
Using two small cups and your forceps, sort the peas into two groups based on their color.
Next, using the paint tray or ice cube tray, try to sort the peas into as many groups as you have compartments, based on color, texture, or any other characteristics you find helpful.
Next, use your sorting trough and arrange the peas in a spectrum based on the colors or textures you see. For example, you might create a spectrum from darkest to lightest, or from smoothest to most wrinkled.
Which sort was easiest? Which sort was hardest? How many different groups of peas do you think there really are? Which method of sorting do you think best represents the variation you observed in the peas?
At first glance, all the peas might look pretty much the same. But when you look closely, you'll find lots of variation in their appearance, from the color of the seed coat, to the presence or absence of speckles, to the texture of the seed coat. This is true for all living things: the individuals of any species differ from one another in many ways—some obvious and some very subtle.
When scientists study a particular species, they want to understand how and why individuals differ from one another. The first step is often to observe, describe, and categorize the variation in different traits.
In this activity, you sorted the peas into two groups, into multiple groups, and into a spectrum. Was one of these methods better than the others? Most people find it more difficult to sort peas into only two groups than to sort into many groups or into a spectrum. That’s because there are more than two colors of peas!
It’s still possible to make two groups—maybe you chose to sort them into dark peas and light peas, for example. But if there is a lot of variation, where to draw the line between dark and light becomes subjective. It was probably easier to sort peas into many groups or into a spectrum, because these methods better capture the natural variation in pea coat color.
However, all of these sorting schemes are essentially human inventions—we are making up these categories and distinctions. There’s no “correct” or natural way to sort the peas—only more useful or less useful ways, depending on what questions you are trying to answer.
This isn’t only true for peas, but for every organism. For example, how easy is it to sort people into groups based on a particular trait—for example, skin color? We can’t easily divide humans into two groups based on skin color. How many groups would we need? How would you draw the line between where one color stopped and another started? Would a continuum be a better way to sort humans by skin color?
Just as there are no natural or inherent categories for sorting peas, there are no natural or inherent categories for sorting humans. Although there are genes that influence skin color, our categories of race and ethnicity were invented by humans, and are not encoded in our DNA.
If you’ve taken a biology class, you might remember the peas studied by Gregor Mendel, an Austrian monk who bred and studied pea plants, and who uncovered some of the basic principles of biological inheritance.
You might also remember that Mendel categorized his peas as either yellow or green, which seems much simpler than the peas you sorted. The difference between Mendel’s peas and your peas is that before he started his experiments, Mendel did many rounds of inbreeding to remove much of the variation in his various pea populations. He created many strains of pea plants that “bred true” when mated to themselves, producing only yellow peas, for example, or only green peas.
Scientists use this approach with all of the model organisms that they study, such as mice or fruit flies. Removing natural variation simplifies the experimental process and makes it easier to answer questions about which genes are influencing a trait. Observing the natural variation in an organism helps remind us how complicated most traits are.
This activity is part of the Phenomenal Genome project, which was supported by the National Institute Of General Medical Sciences of the National Institutes of Health under Award Number R25GM132926. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health.


