Skip to main content

Searching for Significant SNPs

Science Snack
Searching for Significant SNPs
Analyze genetic data to find locations linked to a disease.
Searching for Significant SNPs
Analyze genetic data to find locations linked to a disease.

Everyone has a unique set of DNA sequences. Some variable sequences, known as SNPs, are linked with the chances of having a disease or some other trait. Analyze DNA data and see what you can discover.  

 

Tools and Materials
Assembly

None needed.

To Do and Notice

The human genome (our DNA) is 99.9% identical from one person to the next. So only about 0.1% of our DNA differs between individuals. Most of this variation consists of single-nucleotide polymorphisms, or SNPs. These are places where a single nucleotide (A, T, C, or G) varies from person to person.

Take a look at the asthma data set, and notice what it shows. How many people are included? Notice that there are two groups of people—those with asthma, and those without. How many different nucleotides, or alleles, are there at each SNP? (For example, SNP 1 has two different alleles, A and T.)

Using whatever method or materials you like, organize the data in a way that helps you notice and describe patterns. For example, you might try cutting the data table into strips for each person so you can sort based on which allele they have at each SNP. Or you might try color-coding the alleles to help you see which are more frequent in people with asthma.

Based on your analysis, which alleles do you think are associated with an increased risk of asthma? Which are not associated? How well does each SNP predict asthma?

Based on the data, what would you conclude about the genetic basis of asthma? How much do these SNPs matter?

What’s Going On?

You’ve just modeled the process of a genome-wide association study (GWAS), a method used by scientists to uncover statistical links between genetic variants (usually SNPs) and a particular trait or disease (in this case, asthma).

The data you saw is not real, but it’s similar to the data that scientists use in a GWAS. In a real data set, each person would have two alleles for each SNP—one from each copy of the chromosome. Also, there would be tens of thousands or hundreds of thousands of people. And a real data set might include millions of SNPs.

To find out which SNPs affect a condition or trait, scientists use statistical analysis to compare SNPs among thousands of people. They look for SNPs that are different between people with that condition and people without it.

When you organized the asthma data, you might have noticed that some SNPs were very similar between people with and without asthma. For example, at SNP 2, there are similar numbers of people with Ts and Gs. You probably concluded that SNP 2 isn’t associated with asthma.

On the other hand, you probably noticed that far more people with asthma have a C at SNP 3, and far more people without asthma have an A. Therefore, this SNP is strongly associated with asthma. However, one person with asthma has a C, and one without asthma has an A. That means that while SNP 3 seems to have a big impact on asthma risk, it doesn’t cause asthma all by itself, and it’s not required for developing asthma.

Finally, some SNPs have a weak association with asthma. If you have an A at SNP 1, it seems a little more likely that you’ll have asthma. So this SNP might affect asthma, but not as strongly as SNP 3. (Sometimes, when very weak associations are studied further with a different data set or a different type of analysis, the association disappears. This means it was a statistical artifact, not a true association.)

Modern GWAS studies usually uncover weak associations—SNPs that make you somewhat more or less likely to have a disease or condition. For example, one study found that people who have two copies of T at the SNP called 17q21 were twice as likely to get asthma.

GWAS studies almost never uncover SNPs that are entirely predictive—where everyone with the same allele also has the condition. That’s because most traits are controlled by many, many genes, each with a small effect on the trait.

You might have also noticed that there are two people (person 1 and person 4) with the same set of nucleotides (alleles), yet person 1 has asthma and person 4 doesn’t. If people with the same genotype (DNA sequence) have different phenotypes (traits), then we know asthma is not controlled by genetics alone. The environment must play a role.

Our simplified GWAS study reveals that asthma is a complex disease. It’s affected by many SNPs to varying degrees, and isn’t fully predicted by any one gene.

A GWAS can’t tell us how a particular SNP is involved in controlling a disease or trait. But if the study finds alleles that increase disease risk, scientists can do additional research on those genes to try to learn how they’re involved in the disease, and how it might be treated.

Going Further

Try analyzing the data set for Tay-Sachs disease. This rare and serious disease affects nerves in the brain and spinal cord. How does this data set compare to the asthma data set? What do you think this means about the biological basis of Tay-Sachs disease?

You probably noticed a very different pattern in this data set—all the people with Tay-Sachs have a T at SNP 3, and all the people without the disease have a C. This pattern suggests that a single gene might be the sole cause of the disease, with no influence by other genes or the environment.

Tay-Sachs is caused by a mutation in a single gene coding for an enzyme involved in metabolism. Anyone with two copies of the Tay-Sachs allele will have the disease. Anyone with only one copy will be healthy, though they might pass on the allele onto their children.

Most diseases and traits are more like asthma—we can’t tell from DNA alone whether or not a person will have it.

Resources

Thank you to science educator Whitney Thwaite, who originally developed this activity. 

This activity is part of the Phenomenal Genome project, which was supported by the National Institute Of General Medical Sciences of the National Institutes of Health under Award Number R25GM132926. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health. 

Science Education Partnership Award (SEPA) supported by the National Institutes of Health