Skip to main content

Who's Like You?

Science Snack
Who's Like You?
There’s more than one way to judge who you’re most similar to.
Who's Like You?
There’s more than one way to judge who you’re most similar to.

We compare ourselves to other people every day, noticing similarities and differences. This Science Snack gives you a different way to compare yourself to others, and maybe a new way to think about similarity and difference.

Tools and Materials
  • A group of friends or classmates (not shown)
  • Human Traits Inventory worksheet, two printed copies per person
  • Colored markers
Assembly

None needed.

To Do and Notice

Look around at your friends or classmates. Who do you think is the most biologically similar to you? Interpret that question however you like. Make a note of which person you chose. What traits or characteristics did you think about when making that choice?

Next, use a colored marker to fill out your Human Traits Inventory by circling the answers that best match yours. If you feel like neither option describes you, circle the box in the “Other” column and describe how your version looks. Fill out a second copy of your Traits Inventory and write your name at the top. Put that copy on a wall or table and have everyone else do the same, so the whole group can see them all.

Compare your Traits Inventory to your friends’ or classmates’, and count the number of traits you have in common with each person. Based on the Traits Inventory, which person has the most traits in common with you? Was it the same person you thought was most biologically similar to you?

What’s Going On?

Most likely, the person you first chose as the most biologically similar is not the person you shared the most traits with on the Inventory. When we look around the room and decide who we think we’re most similar to, we tend to compare physical traits associated with socially relevant categories, such as race, ethnicity, gender, sex, or age. Most people assume that they’re most similar to someone with the same hair color, skin color, or ancestral background.

When we sort ourselves using a different set of physical traits, we usually uncover different relationships. That’s because categories like race and ethnicity don’t predict most of our traits, including the shapes of our chins or earlobes. Most of the traits in the inventory are not more common in one race or ethnicity than another, and are not genetically linked to the traits we associate with race and ethnicity, such as skin or hair color. (The one exception is that dry earwax is much more common in certain Asian populations.)

This isn’t only true for visible, physical traits. Knowing a person’s skin color or ancestry doesn’t enable you to predict whether they will have a certain disease or whether they are good at sports. 

Going Further

Why do you think the Traits Inventory includes an “Other” category? Sometimes we assume that traits that vary between individuals are binary, meaning there are only two possibilities. For example, we asked whether your earlobes are attached or unattached.

In reality, there are many possibilities. Your earlobes might be mostly unattached, a little unattached, a little attached, mostly attached, or anything in between. With only two categories, some people have a hard time deciding which one they fit into. That might mean that we need more categories to describe how this trait varies among humans. Or perhaps we should be asking where people fall along a spectrum ranging from one extreme to another. To explore this idea further, check out the Ear Sort Science Snack. 

Resources

This Science Snack is part of the Phenomenal Genome project, which was supported by the National Institute Of General Medical Sciences of the National Institutes of Health under Award Number R25GM132926. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the National Institutes of Health. 

Science Education Partnership Award (SEPA) supported by the National Institutes of Health