Skip to main content

Lego Mechanisms

Ryan Ryan
December 28, 2015
Calculating...
Lego Mechanisms

IMG_6452Five or ten years ago, when I started working with the tinkering studio, there were legos all over the place. Many of the earliest tinkering workshops developed as part of the PIE Network found ways to incorporate Pico Cricket technology and combine explorations of natural phenomenon with in-depth investigations of logo programming and lego mechanisms. As the group shifted focus from intensive professional development workshops to drop-in experiences suitable for the museum floor, the complications of these lego based elements took a back seat to designing activities, facilitation, and environments to support direct tinkering with materials and phenomenon. But recently, some strands of work have come together to reignite our interest in developing legos as a method of prototyping and resource for workshops. Back in the summer, Mike and Karen spent a sabbatical at the home of Lego in Bilund and met with the Lego Foundation team, who are interested in the educational possibilities of play. And just last week, a group of experts on the subject of 'learning through play' convened at the Exploratorium to continue some of those initial discussions. IMG_6327In the meantime, experiments with beetleblocks on the floor and other programming elements have piqued our interest about finding ways to incorporate the digital and physical world through tinkering. This summer, Noga Elhassid and Lianna led the group in experiments with cardboard linkages as ways of transferring mechanical movement in whimsical creations. And finally, in some of our more established tinkering activities like Light Play and Chain Reaction, we've been thinking about how to prototype new additions and elements.

IMG_6355So after receiving a generous supply of parts in the mail from the foundation, we've played around a bit and discovered that legos are a interesting way to prototype in all three of these areas. IMG_6392We started off with some research into mechanisms, both lego and otherwise. One of our favorite sources for inspiration, no matter what material is 507 Mechanical Movements by Henry T Brown. As we've gone deeper into the world of lego, Amos Blanton, from the foundation, recommended the books of Yoshihito Isogawa who makes elegant, clear, and creative lego mechanisms that can work as the building blocks to create more complex creations.

IMG_6139When we constructed some gear mechanisms for the chain reaction materials last week we thought about how to mount them on a block of wood a la circuit boards with screws to make it more sturdy and accessible. Something like this is really simple but allows for a lot of variation as the arms can be moved and adjusted easily with the technic connectors. One of the things that we like a lot about building with this system is that it's easy to quickly adjust and return to the exact original position, something that's impossible with masking tape and cardboard. IMG_6141Other of the mechanisms were more complicated like this pneumatic pump system that inflated a balloon to knock a ball down a track. At this point these chain reaction elements are prototypes and don't work perfectly, but we're already learning about how they work in the chain reaction activity.

IMG_6351The lego parts make it easier to experiment with different types of gears based mechanisms. Nicole created a "gearing down system" by building a chain of big and small gears linked together to slow down the speed and increase the amount of force exerted. This was inspired by some similar art pieces and exhibits by Arthur Ganson and others on display at the museum. IMG_6365The second iteration worked to gear down a motor to make it very slow and powerful. We attached a winch to the end of the last gear and lifted a heavy (10 lb) weight which wouldn't be possible without the system in place. Even if the final system would work better with stronger pieces, I think it's interesting that working with the legos for a few hours really gave Nicole the chance to learn through experience of trial and error that she could apply to other projects.

IMG_6442Later on we got a little silly and tested out if the motor was strong enough to pull Sebastian toward a mince pie while seated on a chair on a dolly. Although a little absurd, this sort of system could be really useful for chain reaction, especially as a relatively small object that could control a large starting point or finale.

With all these mechanisms we are exploring a bit of a tension between the ease and reliability of purely using the lego system and the open-endedness and creativity of working with materials like cardboard or wire. It's not clear whether lego is a good system for prototyping before using more everyday materials, something that can be combined with other consumables, or can provide satisfactory tinkering experiences on its own for visitors. Like any new material, there's the need to develop an understanding of the affordances and possibilities, and by building some of these chain reaction mechanisms we've begun to develop more of a fluency with the system. In the next post, I'll share more about the ways that we've played with legos to expand on cardboard linkage experiments and develop new ways to explore the underlying principles.